Signal blocks screenshots to keep AI agents out
· BehindLines newsroom
The encrypted messaging app Signal now restricts screenshots in its mobile apps. According to TechCrunch, the announcement was made on Friday and targets operating systems that integrate artificial intelligence agents able to "scan" what is shown on screen.
What Signal decided
Meredith Whittaker, Signal's president, considers that Windows, Android, macOS and iOS "undermine Signal's ability to guarantee privacy," according to TechCrunch. She explains that sensitive data is captured and then made accessible to a local database or a remote server used by the agent, beyond Signal's control. The block already existed in the Windows app; it now extends to Android and iOS. According to The Register, the new versions by default prevent Apple's Siri on iOS, as well as Gemini and other agents running on Android, from taking screenshots that these agents analyse through character recognition.
A setting that can be changed
Users can turn the protection off in the settings if they want to photograph their conversations, but Ms Whittaker warns, according to both outlets, that this weakens the privacy guarantees. She also acknowledges that it is an incomplete solution, because agents might reach an application's data by other routes. According to The Register, Ms Whittaker says Signal cannot yet apply these protections on macOS, because system vendors provide no tools to restrict agents' access without degrading the experience.
The position of Apple and the others
Again according to The Register, Apple is preparing, with macOS 27.3, now in public testing, finer controls for full disk access and for certain interfaces. The outlet notes that this measure seems aimed mainly at third parties rather than at Apple's own assistant Siri. Apple writes that the risks grow as agents become more autonomous, and says it wants users to understand them before granting access.
The outlet places the initiative in a wider movement: Amazon has blocked some shopping agents on its online store, while United Airlines bans transactions made by unauthorised bots, according to The Register. It describes a reaction after a year or two in which agent vendors argued for access to all data in order to personalise their services better.
Why it matters
For The Register, Apple, Google and Microsoft do not give developers sufficient controls over AI agents. Signal itself admits that its measure is partial and that developers, Signal included, lack solid tools to protect privacy at the level of their applications.