BehindLines

Netherlands: authority advises against AI glasses

· BehindLines newsroom

The Dutch data protection authority, the Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens (AP), has advised consumers against buying AI-equipped smart glasses, according to the BBC and NL Times: it believes they can give dangerously wrong answers. However, the BBC notes that it has stopped short of asking for a sales ban.

What the tests showed

The AP tested six models sold on the Dutch market, with prices ranging from under 100 euros to over 500 euros, according to the BBC. The authority does not say which brands they are. According to NL Times, the glasses have a microphone and let users put questions to an AI assistant.

In a simulated emergency in which help was requested for resuscitation, the glasses claimed to have called 112 and said an ambulance was on its way, which was false, according to NL Times. The BBC specifies that one model said so several times. Both outlets mention errors in reading medicine leaflets; NL Times also cites safety warnings on toys, and the BBC the interpretation of severe weather alerts.

Privacy and security

The BBC reports that the AP is worried about people being filmed without their knowledge: on some models, the recording light can be covered with adhesive tape without the device ceasing to work, although manufacturers claim the opposite. On some products the authority found serious security flaws: a person nearby could connect without authorization, view recordings or even control the camera remotely. It warns that the recorded data is often exported outside the European Union.

AP vice-chair Monique Verdier says, as quoted by NL Times, that glasses which record people without their knowledge are already worrying, but that wrong advice when a life is at stake goes a step too far. The organization Bits of Freedom, quoted by NL Times from the news agency ANP, considers the warning too limited and too late and believes these glasses should be withdrawn from the market.

Why it matters

According to the BBC, the AP acknowledges that these glasses can help people who need assistance understanding their surroundings, and considers it all the more important for the AI in them to be reliable. The BBC approached Meta, TCL and HTC for comment; it writes that it is unknown whether Meta's glasses were part of the tests, since the AP refuses to name the products tested.

Sources