Hunger Games: the new prequel divides critics
· BehindLines newsroom
The sixth film in the Hunger Games series, The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping, arrives in cinemas this weekend. According to the BBC, the first reviews are sharply divided. US public radio network NPR, for its part, publishes a rather reserved verdict.
The film's subject
In the saga's chronology, the story is set 24 years before the first film and 40 years after the 2023 prequel, the BBC explains. It tells the youth of Haymitch Abernathy, played at 16 by Joseph Zada; in the first film, the character was played by Woody Harrelson. According to NPR, the young man is drawn for the fiftieth edition of the Games, which has twice as many participants as usual, 48 in total.
A packed cast
NPR mentions Jesse Plemons, Elle Fanning as Effie Trinket and Kieran Culkin as Caesar Flickerman. The BBC adds Ralph Fiennes, Glenn Close, Mckenna Grace and Maya Hawke. NPR doubts that Joseph Zada is up to his character and finds the supporting roles remarkable. The Hollywood Reporter, quoted by the BBC, takes the opposite view and describes a role that makes a star.
The reviews gathered by the BBC
The BBC compiled several British and American reviews. The Guardian gives one star and finds the film overwrought and boring. Empire gives three stars and sees it as a decent but secondary diversion. Screen Daily regrets weak characters. IndieWire and the New York Times use the same word, "slog", to describe a heavy-going film.
By contrast, The Wrap praises memorable performances and a gripping style. Time Out gives four stars and finds it as strong as any other installment. The Hollywood Reporter sees a return to the spirit of the first films, after the 2023 prequel it finds disappointing.
What NPR says
NPR's review faults the film for not making it convincing how Haymitch comes out on top in the arena. It also considers that the violence is toned down compared with earlier films and that the franchise, once strongly political, is losing momentum. It recalls that the 2023 prequel had the lowest box office of the series, and notes that all five of Suzanne Collins's novels have now been adapted.
Why it matters
The reviews cited here are journalists' opinions. The sources consulted give neither box-office figures nor audience reactions.