BehindLines

Parthenon: a Frankfurt museum rebuilds the east pediment

· BehindLines newsroom

The Liebieghaus (Frankfurt), a sculpture museum, has been presenting a reconstruction of the Parthenon's east pediment since 18 November. According to Deutsche Welle, the archaeologist Vinzenz Brinkmann, who heads the museum's antiquities department, and his team have put together all the surviving fragments of this sculpted ensemble. The exhibition, titled "Athena, the Stage is Yours" with the subtitle "The Parthenon Puzzle", runs until 25 July 2027.

A forty-year puzzle

Above the entrance of the temple in Athens, the east pediment showed the birth of Athena, who emerged from the head of Zeus. According to Deutsche Welle, 39 figures adorned this composition, which was about 29 meters long. The German outlet links its destruction to the Christianization of Greece, whereas The Art Newspaper writes that nobody knows when or why it happened, sometime between the 5th century and 1670. On what remains, the two outlets give figures that are presented differently: Deutsche Welle says that about 20% of the original volume is known to have survived, while The Art Newspaper states that 80% is still missing. The fragments are scattered across several European museums, most of them in the Greek capital, and the British Museum also holds a large number.

According to Deutsche Welle, Vinzenz Brinkmann, together with his spouse Ulrike Koch-Brinkmann, has spent over forty years on this riddle. The Art Newspaper recounts that in 1986 he climbed up to the temple at night with a rope to examine the base of the pediment under special lamps, and found nothing.

The clue from Roman sarcophagi

In 2014, during a visit to the Hermitage Museum in Saint Petersburg, the team noticed on a Roman sarcophagus lid a relief linked to the birth of Athena. Nine sarcophagi of this type are known, almost all of them in Rome, and each one shows a different part of the pediment, according to Deutsche Welle. Also according to this outlet, the researchers examined about 60 original fragments, scanned with a simple iPhone, and then fitted them together by computer. The Art Newspaper adds that, according to the team, the remaining fragments and the figures on the reliefs match 100%.

Among the surprises cited by The Art Newspaper: the twin horsemen Castor and Pollux (the Dioscuri) appeared on the pediment, standing beside rearing horses that they hold by the reins. Brinkmann sees this as one of the consequences of Athena's birth, which he describes as a primordial cosmic event.

A Greek loan withdrawn

The exhibition was meant to bring together pieces from the Acropolis Museum of Athens and from the British Museum. The Art Newspaper reports that the Greek government took back the nine fragments it had agreed to lend; per Greek media cited by the newspaper, the Central Archaeological Council of Greece refused because these pieces would have been shown next to fragments from the London museum, and the Greek ministry in charge of culture did not respond to its requests for comment. Deutsche Welle writes that Greece pulled out once it found out that the British Museum also intended to lend pieces. Greece has demanded for decades the return of the marbles taken in the 19th century by Lord Elgin, while the United Kingdom says it acquired them legally, Deutsche Welle recalls.

The two outlets do not describe the same situation for the British fragments: Deutsche Welle says the Liebieghaus finally gave them up, whereas The Art Newspaper quotes a British Museum spokesperson who confirms that the loan of two fragments is going ahead. We do not decide between these two versions.

Why it matters

The Parthenon is regarded as one of the great masterpieces of classical Greek art, Deutsche Welle points out. Vinzenz Brinkmann says he is very confident that he has solved the riddle. The two articles consulted mainly report his explanations and those of the museum; they do not quote an outside specialist assessing this reconstruction.

Sources