US data centres emit CO2 comparable to Denmark's
· BehindLines newsroom
The largest data centres in the United States released about 25.7 million metric tons of CO2 in one year, according to a Harvard University study published on Monday, November 16, in the journal Nature Sustainability. Denmark: that is the country to which CBC and The Verge compare this total, the former describing more emissions than Denmark's, the latter a comparable level.
What the study measured
The researchers identified 403 "hyperscale" data centres from satellite images, then estimated each one's consumption from its electrical capacity, according to The Verge. Drawing on data from the US environmental agency, they assessed the emissions each centre would have produced had it been connected to the local grid between May 2024 and April 2025. The result: about 82 terawatt-hours of electricity, or 1.8% of the country's consumption, and 25.7 million metric tons of CO2, according to The Verge and CBC.
Electricity that is still very fossil-based
More than half of that electricity came from fossil fuels, according to CBC; The Verge puts the share from gas and coal at 54%. CBC adds that coal supplied 15% of the total. Francesca Dominici, the study's senior author, judges, according to CBC, that this figure is between two and three times that of earlier work. The period studied came before the recent rise of artificial intelligence, CBC recalls, so current emissions are probably higher.
Location matters as much as the machine
According to The Verge, generating electricity in Wyoming, which depends heavily on coal, emits about seven times more CO2 per kilowatt-hour than in Oregon, which is rich in hydropower. Gianluca Guidi, the lead author, tells The Verge that two centres using the same energy can have very different footprints depending on where they are. Fengqi You of Cornell University, who was not part of the study, warns of a "carbon lock-in": power plants built for these needs can run for decades.
Acknowledged limits
The figures rest on models, because operators publish little data about their consumption, both outlets stress. CBC says outside experts consider the method reasonable. The study does not account for local air pollution linked to gas turbines, according to The Verge. The authors are preparing a website to track the impact of each centre.
Why it matters
The study quantifies the footprint of large-scale computing and shows that it depends heavily on how electricity is produced. Gianluca Guidi, quoted by The Verge, sees an encouraging point in this: these effects are not inevitable, because it is possible to choose where to build and how to power the infrastructure. According to Fengqi You, quoted by CBC, the footprint depends on where the centres are built, how efficient they are and where their electricity comes from.