BehindLines

Beauty advent calendars: the Skims row reopens the debate

· BehindLines newsroom

Are beauty advent calendars, often priced above £100, good value? The question is back in the spotlight after the row over the Skims calendar, according to the BBC and the CBC, whose article was published around 10 November.

Skims offers to refund its calendar

According to the CBC, Kim Kardashian's brand is offering a full refund, or a credit, to everyone who bought its calendar, after sharp criticism from customers; the BBC also reports refunds offered to all. Priced at 148 US dollars (276 Canadian dollars, or £110 according to the BBC), it is billed as "12 days of surprises" and contains, among other things, hair elastics, hairpins and key rings. Unboxing videos posted by disappointed customers have circulated, one of them passing 20 million views by Monday morning, the CBC says. A spokesperson for Skims said the firm knew of this feedback and acknowledged that, for some customers, the calendar had not lived up to expectations. According to the CBC, the product was sold out, with a waiting list, at the time of publication.

A market driven by marketing

The BBC notes that these calendars have existed for more than ten years and that their promotion has become more sophisticated: warnings that stock may run out, which can lift demand, and unboxing videos by influencers. According to Ipsos data cited by the BBC, about 15% of advent calendars sold are beauty calendars, with 18-34-year-olds the most willing to spend. This is not the first such case, the CBC points out: Chanel was criticised online in 2021 over a $1,025 calendar full of trinkets, and Dior followed.

More discerning customers

The BBC gathers mixed views. Julia, 39, paid £99 this year for a John Lewis fragrance calendar, after £160 at Space NK last year; she reckons the products she keeps cost less per millilitre than in a shop, and she swaps the ones she does not want through a Facebook group. Fashion journalist Priya Raj rarely buys them but sees the value of trying products in small sizes. Heather Widdows, a professor of philosophy and beauty specialist, considers it very unlikely that anyone would use every product in a calendar, and therefore judges that they are probably not worth the price.

Why it matters

The BBC asks whether these calendars benefit brands and customers alike, or mainly exist to make people spend more before the festive season, without settling the question. The views gathered by the two outlets are personal: they are neither a market study nor a buying recommendation.

Sources