Italy fines Meta €805 million over Android photos
· BehindLines newsroom
Italy's data protection authority on Saturday, November 14, fined Meta, the group behind Facebook, Instagram and WhatsApp, €805 million after it reached the photos of Android users without having their specific consent. According to the BBC, it ranks among the heaviest ever imposed by an Italian authority on a technology giant; Deutsche Welle (DW) describes it as the biggest sum Italian regulators have ever levied on a large firm of the sector.
What the regulator alleges
According to the BBC, the authority holds that around 20 million smartphone users were not properly told that Meta could look at their photos and videos through one function of the Facebook app. The feature suggests images from the phone's gallery as ideas for posts. The BBC explains that the app asked for gallery access through a single app-wide permission, and that an earlier message failed to say this permission also served to produce such suggestions. According to DW, the authority faults Meta for not collecting specific consent and for not properly informing the people concerned.
A fine and a deadline
DW says the amount corresponds to 0.4% of Meta's yearly turnover. The group has two months (60 days) to switch the suggestion feature off by default and to ask users separately for their agreement. According to the BBC, the authority weighed the large number of people concerned, a practice still running for users who skipped the app update and for users who had already agreed, and also the company's insufficient cooperation. The investigation was opened in July 2025, DW adds.
Meta's response
Meta announced that it would appeal. A spokesperson told the BBC that the company strongly disagrees with its reading of the facts, the way the law was applied and the size of the fine, which it deems disproportionate. He says the feature simply helps people post photos, and that users must first grant a permission on their device, which can be changed at any time in settings. According to DW, Meta also argued that the case falls under the jurisdiction of Ireland, where its European headquarters is located, an argument the Italian regulator rejected. DW notes that the company had already denied using this feature to train AI models, an aspect the Italian authority did not examine.
Why it matters
The decision concerns how Meta requested access to photos stored on Android phones. It is not final, since Meta has announced an appeal, the outcome of which is not known.