U2 releases "Carnaval de Luz", its first album in almost ten years
· BehindLines newsroom
The Irish band U2 is releasing "Carnaval de Luz", its sixteenth studio album and its first record of new songs in nearly a decade, according to The Guardian. Reviews in the British daily and on the US public radio network NPR see a return to form, with some nuances.
A reunited band
The Guardian notes that drummer Larry Mullen Jr. is back behind his kit after medical problems, and that the band seems delighted to play together in a room again. The opening track, "Go (Carnaval de Luz)", combines electronically treated guitars, a pounding rhythm and synthesisers by Brian Eno, according to the paper. The Guardian also reports that Bono described this return to loud guitars as a way of facing an anxious era with a more defiant joy.
Nods to the past and to Rosalía
NPR describes an album that travels across the band's past "with unapologetic delight": the critic hears in the opening an echo of "The Fly", from "Achtung Baby", and in "Silencio" a reminder of "Two Hearts Beat as One". NPR also notes that Bono revealed one track was named after his "platonic muse" Rosalía, and judges this interest in Latin music less an appropriation than an extension of the cosmopolitanism of "Achtung Baby". The Guardian sees in "The Mirror Maker" a call-and-response tribute to the Catalan superstar, rather excitable but certainly fun. The record ends with "Torn", a duet with Dolly Parton, which the Guardian describes as her last vocal performance.
Faith at the centre
Both publications stress the place of spirituality. For NPR, Bono's lyrics express a Christian faith more directly than before; the text adds that non-religious listeners could feel ill at ease with this fervour. The Guardian notes a greater number of spiritual allusions and metaphors than on any of the band's albums for years, as well as several of the earnest, heavily stressed phrases Bono is fond of.
Two verdicts
In the Guardian, the critic believes the music is impassioned enough to uplift the listener and that it ranks among the finest things the band has made for over thirty years. The critic regrets that the songs from two EPs released this year appear only on the deluxe edition. For NPR, the album leaves U2 "admirable again, if not exactly cool".
Why it matters
According to the Guardian, the last twenty years have been a succession of creative turbulence for U2, with no record matching its early albums. NPR, for its part, describes a band that has been reigning for half a century. These are two critics' opinions, not a consensus.