Obesity: a study tests a definition that goes beyond BMI
· BehindLines newsroom
A study published on 11 November in the journal Nature proposes to stop diagnosing obesity with body mass index (BMI) alone, the ratio of weight to height. It covers nearly 850,000 adults and feeds a debate among specialists, reported by the Reuters agency and by Medscape Medical News.
A two-step definition
The work tests the framework proposed in 2025 by a commission of The Lancet Diabetes & Endocrinology, chaired by Francesco Rubino of King's College London, the study's senior author. It combines BMI with measures of body fat, such as waist circumference, then looks for signs of weight-related organ dysfunction. Reuters explains that so-called preclinical obesity means excess fat without organ damage, and clinical obesity means excess fat together with such damage. According to the agency, the World Health Organization estimates that more than one billion people live with obesity.
The reported results
The researchers analyzed 844,108 adults from four groups followed in China, the United Kingdom, the United States and Spain. According to Reuters, 1% to 3% of people classed as obese by BMI would not be under the new approach, while a further 5% to 9% would be. On average, about 27% of people with obesity would fall under the clinical form, close to 8.5% of adults. Medscape reports, for all-cause mortality, a risk 69% higher with clinical obesity and 19% higher with the preclinical form, without specifying the comparison group. About 82% of preclinical cases did not progress to the clinical form, Reuters indicates.
Reservations
According to Medscape, Amy Rothberg of the University of Michigan, who responded on behalf of the Endocrine Society to the 2025 proposal, considers that BMI misclassification remains modest and that the added complexity is hardly justified. She also finds it hard to apply the requirement to prove that organ damage comes from excess fat. An Pan, the first author, says the team is seeking to refine the criteria, as some clinicians wonder whether fewer criteria would suffice. Another study, in the International Journal of Obesity, on nearly 7,000 British people aged 46, concludes that 69% of those obese by BMI are not clinically so, according to Medscape.
Why it matters
This work touches on how obesity would be defined and counted. Reuters notes that, across a population, a difference of a few percentage points could affect tens of millions of people. The data come from four cohorts; Reuters and Medscape detail no concrete change to care, and the framework remains debated.