A variant inherited from Neanderthals linked to a brain region
· BehindLines newsroom
A small difference in our DNA (ADN), inherited from Neanderthals (Néandertal), is associated with a smaller volume in one brain region. That is what Svante Pääbo and Hugo Zeberg, who work at the Max Planck Society's evolutionary anthropology institute (Max-Planck) in Leipzig describe in a study published in the journal PNAS, reported by Nature and ScienceAlert.
A piece of DNA of Neanderthal origin
According to Nature, the researchers compared ancient DNA with data from sources including the 1000 Genomes Project and the UK Biobank. The variant is the loss of four nucleotides on chromosome 14, first identified in 2019. It appears in all five detailed Neanderthal genomes available, but not in Denisovans (Denisoviens), another extinct human group. In modern humans it occurs only in people of non-African ancestry, which, according to ScienceAlert, fits the history of interbreeding with Neanderthals after the move out of Africa.
Nature considers it unlikely that the variant comes from a species ancestral to both humans and Neanderthals (Néandertaliens): it lies in a block of DNA 59.7 kilobases long, too large to have lasted hundreds of thousands of years. ScienceAlert puts the block at nearly 60,000 DNA letters.
An unexpected effect on the brain
According to Nature, Neanderthal brains were longer from front to rear, while modern brains are more rounded, and Neanderthals often had somewhat larger occipital lobes, the rear region that processes visual information. Yet each copy of the variant is associated with a volume 0.85 cubic centimetres smaller in one part of that lobe, the cuneus, an effect larger than that of any other known variant, Nature reports. "This is a very important variant," says Davide Marnetto of the University of Turin, quoted by the magazine.
Zeberg tells ScienceAlert that many genes and other factors, among them eye and body size, shape the anatomy of the brain, and that one variant of Neanderthal origin does not necessarily reflect their anatomy as a whole.
Links to treat with caution
The variant lies near the DAAM1 gene, which plays a role in brain development; according to ScienceAlert, the researchers suspect an influence on how it is expressed. By cross-checking psychiatric genetic data, the team observed a slightly lower risk of schizophrenia among carriers, about 5% per copy, according to ScienceAlert. The researchers have not established whether this link runs through the volume of the occipital lobe; Zeberg says that question remains unanswered for now. ScienceAlert adds that they found no significant association with general intelligence.
Why it matters
The authors, quoted by ScienceAlert, caution against equating the size of a brain region with cognitive abilities. Nature stresses that the variant's effect on brain anatomy is unusually strong. This is a statistical association: whether the lower schizophrenia risk is directly tied to the smaller occipital lobe remains, according to Zeberg, an open question.