Etsy: sellers leave the platform over AI
· BehindLines newsroom
The online marketplace Etsy is facing anger from some of its sellers. The cause is new terms of use that allow the company and its partners to use shop content for artificial intelligence technologies. Several creators are removing their products or closing their shops, CBC and PC Gamer report.
What the new terms say
According to PC Gamer, which quotes the text, the terms take effect on 16 December. They provide that sellers' content may be used to develop, train, test and improve AI and machine learning technologies, including by the company's partners and vendors. CBC describes the same clause.
Sellers who are leaving
CBC quotes Tsuki Matsuba, in Vancouver, who is pulling her custom stationery items. For her, the measure is "a kick in the teeth". After seven years in animation, she says she lost her job in part because of AI, and she fears shop owners are forced to choose between holiday income and staying on the platform. In Ottawa, the artist Tina Nawrocki says she is closing her shop, while in Halifax The Calendork has removed its artwork but is keeping the shop open, according to CBC.
Etsy's answer
James Ossman, who leads customer operations, says in a statement that creative work belongs to sellers. According to him, Etsy does not use this content to train models designed to copy or replace original creation. He mentions uses such as translating listing descriptions, featuring photos in promotional campaigns, or optimisation and statistics tools for shops, PC Gamer reports. He also acknowledges that the company should have communicated better about these changes, according to CBC, and says it wants to keep talking with sellers. PC Gamer adds, in an update, that Etsy told the New York Times it intends to revise the policy.
What remains disputed
PC Gamer notes that Mr Ossman's commitments do not appear in the terms themselves, whose legal wording remains, in the site's view, imprecise. Other sellers call for voluntary participation rather than automatic participation; the site writes that there is apparently no opt-out option. It also recalls that the controversy comes a few weeks after Etsy banned AI-generated recipes and patterns.
Why it matters
The episode pits sellers worried about their creations being used for AI against a platform that says it does not aim to copy or replace their work. Etsy told the New York Times, according to PC Gamer, that it intends to revise the policy, but neither outlet puts a figure on how many sellers have left.