BehindLines

Brain: an area tied to listening also helps produce speech

· BehindLines newsroom

A small portion of a brain region known for listening also plays a role just before a word is spoken. That is the conclusion of a study published on November 19 in the journal Science and presented on November 15 at the yearly gathering of the Society for Neuroscience, according to Science News and Live Science.

A question open for about 150 years

In the 19th century, the German neurologist Carl Wernicke described, on the left side of the brain, an area needed to understand speech. People whose area is damaged understand words poorly, but some also struggle to produce them: sounds get swapped or a word is replaced by a neighboring one, Science News reports, quoting Edward Chang, based at the San Francisco campus of the University of California. Chang sums up the difficulty: why would damage to a listening area disturb speech? That question had remained open for around 150 years.

What the researchers measured

According to Live Science, 28 participants with epilepsy, already fitted with implanted electrodes, took part in the team's recordings; Science News specifies that they were being monitored before surgery for epilepsy or a tumor. A small group of cells in Wernicke's area became active about a quarter of a second before a word was uttered, and also reacted when words were heard. According to Science News, these cells have preferences: they become more active before a long word than before a short one.

Live Science notes that these recordings alone do not prove a causal link. The researchers therefore examined the brains of hundreds of people operated on for a temporal lobe tumor: speech was more often disturbed after the operation when Wernicke's area had been affected. In 13 people whose area was intact, electrical stimulation just before speaking produced word errors resembling those of Wernicke's aphasia, Live Science reports. According to Science News, this disruption of speech production appeared only in that small spot.

Reactions and a technical lead

Jeffrey Binder, who works at the Medical College of Wisconsin, considers, according to Science News, that the study offers persuasive proof that this area is critical to producing speech. Adeen Flinker of New York University, who did not take part in the work, tells Live Science that the study explains speech errors already known. Co-author Alexander Silva believes, according to Live Science, that these results rewrite what textbooks say about Wernicke's area.

In two paralyzed volunteers, experimental implants picked up both the words the volunteers heard and the ones they attempted to say, according to Science News. For Silva, quoted by Live Science, this area could become an additional target for brain-computer interfaces intended for people with aphasia, that is, a language disorder linked to injury to the cortex itself. Science News adds that some implant research concentrates on the motor cortex.

Why it matters

According to Science News, these findings could assist attempts to give back voices to people who no longer speak; Chang also mentions better understanding of situations involving both listening and speaking, for example differences in speaking or understanding among autistic people or the first steps of children learning to talk. The articles present these prospects as leads arising from research work.

Sources